Finding the perfect mascara can be hard. But finding one that also doesn’t test on animals feels like a needle in a hack stack. So, I created this list filled with the best cruelty-free mascaras to make your search easy.
Keep reading to find the best mascara for your lashes!
In a hurry? Here are our top picks!
Tarte Lights Camera Lashes
Too Faced Better Than Sex
Urban Decay Perversion
100% Pure Natural Mascara
List of Cruelty-Free Mascara
- Tarte Lights Camera Lashes Mascara
- Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
- Urban Decay Perversion Mascara
- 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Natural Mascara
- Covergirl Flourish Mascara
- Milk Makeup Kush Vegan Mascara
- Illamasqua Masquara Mascara
- NYX Worth The Hype Mascara
- INIKA Long Lash Vegan Mascara
- Eyeko Lash Alert Mascara
- RMS Beauty Defining Mascara
- Pacifica Stellar Gaze Vegan Mascara
- PÜR Fully Charged Anti-Aging Mascara
- ILIA Limitless Lash Clean Mascara
- Chantecaille Faux Cils Mascara
Best Cruelty-Free Mascara
1. Tarte Lights Camera Lashes Mascara
Tarte Lights Camera Lashes is a 4-in-1 natural mascara that lengths, curls, conditions, and volumizes your lashes in one application. It is formulated using plant botanicals and waxes that condition your lashes. Lights Camera Lashes is non-toxic and free of fragrance, sulfates, petrochemicals, parabens, preservatives, gluten, oil, dye, and talc.
Pros
- Goes on easy
- Lashes look thicker and longer
- Thickens and lengthens in one coat
- Can use it for different eye makeup effects
Cons
- Clumps and flakes
- Dries out in tube
2. Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara was voted as the #1 selling mascara in America in 2019. It is formulated to lengthen, curl, and thicken your lashes with one coat. Better Than Sex has an hourglass-shaped brush that helps you achieve maximum lift and volume with every stroke. Also available as waterproof mascara.
Pros
- No need for fake eyelashes
- Turn fine lashes into long thick eyelashes
- Adds volume and length without being clumpy
Cons
- Too liquidy
- Can clump with more than one coat
- Messy to clean
3. Urban Decay Perversion Mascara
Urban Decay Perversion is a high-end mascara that will give you bigger, badass lashes. It is formulated to be extra creamy to glide through and separate your lashes. It’s perfect for achieving volumizing, eyelash length.
Pros
- Adds length without clumping
- Thick and full lashes
- Does not flake or smudge
Cons
- Smears on eyelids
- Brush is too big
4. 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Natural Mascara
100% Pure is the best natural mascara on the market. It is formulated using non-toxic ingredients that condition, strengthen, and grow your lashes. 100% Pure is smudge-proof, colored with black tea, and free of eye irritating chemicals.
Pros
- Smells fantastic
- Very easy to remove
- Separates lashes
- Stays on all-day
Cons
- Not waterproof
- Mascara squeezes out of container
- Not enough length and volume
- Can smudge
5. Covergirl Flourish Blast Mascara
Covergirl Flourish mascara is created with nourishing ingredients like avocado and papaya oil. The formula is creamy which helps define your lashes without clumping. Flourish Blast is ophthalmologically tested and safe for wearers of contact lenses.
Pros
- Easy to remove
- Helps lashes grow
- Stays on all-day
- Does not clump
Cons
- Not enough volume
- Some flaking
6. Milk Makeup Kush Vegan Mascara
Milk Makeup vegan mascara has heart-shaped fibers that help add length, volume, and curl to your lashes. It contains hemp-derived cannabis oil that allows for smooth application, extra conditioning, and ease of removal.
Pros
- Goes on smooth
- Lifts and curls lashes
- Makes lashes look full and long
- Does not irritate eyes
Cons
- Too thick and clumpy
- Doesn’t last long
7. Illamasqua Masquara Mascara
Illamasqua mascara is perfect for anyone wanting a dramatic lash. It is formulated to lengthen, curl, and volumize your lashes without flaking or smudging. Illamasque contains Vitamin E that intensifies the color while conditioning your lashes.
Pros
- Makes lashes super long
- Full brush makes a great application
- Wonderful coverage in one stroke
Cons
- Slightly clumpy if you apply too much
- Can come off if using a setting spray
- Flakes and smudges throughout the day
8. NYX Worth The Hype Volumizing Mascara
NYX Worth The Hype mascara comes with a tapered brush that coats each lash. It is formulated to give you maximum length and volume all day long. NYX is available in natural and more daring colors to step up your eye makeup game.
Pros
- Lashes look longer and fuller
- No smudging
- Lightweight
- Easy to remove
Cons
- Some flaking
- Color not as bright or vivid
- Not waterproof
9. INIKA Long Lash Vegan Mascara
Inika vegan mascara is perfect for anyone with sensitive skin or easily irritated eyes. It is formulated using vegan, non-toxic, and organic ingredients. Inika mascara contains various ingredients like Sunflower Seed Oil and Vitamin E that condition and encourage lash growth.
Pros
- Makes it look you have eyelashes
- Easy to remove
- Doesn’t clump and lengthens lashes
- Last all-day
Cons
- Flakes throughout the day
10. Eyeko Lash Alert Zero Waste Mascara
Eyeko Lash Alert is created using Korean technology that locks in the color for at least 12 hours. It is formulated using botanical ingredients that will volumize, condition, and lift your lashes all day long.
Pros
- Looks the same throughout the day
- No flakes or clumps
- The brush separates lashes and goes on smooth
- Only need to apply once
Cons
- Comes off like waterproof mascara
- Brush is too skinny
- Clumped or dried out in the tube
11. RMS Beauty Defining Mascara
RMS Beauty Mascara is created using organic ingredients like sunflower seed oil, beeswax, and carnauba wax. Its’ easy to apply formula separates lashes naturally giving you an amazing look!
Pros
- Applicator is thin and easy to handle
- Does not irritate sensitive eyes or contacts
- No clumps and does not flake off
- Beautiful coverage
Cons
- Not much volume or length
- Brush picks up clumps from tube
12. Pacifica Stellar Gaze Vegan Mascara
Pacifica Stellar Gaze is a natural, long-lasting mascara that will nourish, strengthen, and lengthen your lashes. It is formulated using vegan and non-toxic ingredients such as Vitamin B and coconut water. Pacifica mascara does not contain mineral oil, petroleum, phthalates, parabens, or silicone.
Pros
- Makes lashes look natural
- Last all-day
- Does not clump
- Easy to remove
Cons
- Understated lash look
- Not much volume or length
13. PÜR Fully Charged Anti-Aging Mascara
PÜR anti-aging mascara is created with technology that separates, defines, and instantly lifts each lash. It is paraben, gluten-free, and infused with peptides to give you a luxurious lash without clumping, flaking, or smearing.
Pros
- Last all day and stays in place
- No smudging or clumping
- Gives full natural look
- Does not irritate sensitive eyes
Cons
- Can be difficult to remove
- Dry and clumpy in tube
- More expensive than drugstore mascara
14. ILIA Limitless Lash Clean Mascara
ILIA Limitless Mascara is made with natural and organic ingredients that will lengthen, lift, and curl your lashes. It is perfect for those with sensitive eyes who want a flake-free, lifted lash that lasts throughout the day.
Pros
- No clumping
- Gentle for sensitive eyes
- Last all-day
- Gives a natural look
Cons
- Not enough volume
- Some smearing
15. Chantecaille Faux Cils Mascara
Chantecaille mascara uses a peptide technology to make your lashes look fuller, thicker, and longer. It is a non-clumping formula and includes a double helix brush to help your lashes achieve maximum volume.
Pros
- Effortless achieve natural lash
- No clumping, flaking, or transferring
- Nourishes your lashes
- Lashes look longer and fuller
Cons
- Expensive
Wrap Up: Best Cruelty-Free Mascara
There are so many mascaras on the market today. But many of them contain harsh ingredients, test on animals, or just plain suck! This list narrows down your cruelty-free mascara search to just the best of the best. I hope you were able to find one that will give you amazing lashes.
Want more cruelty-free cosmetics? Check out these posts:
- 7 Best Cruelty-Free Sunscreens in 2020
- 21 Cruelty-Free Beauty Boxes in 2020
- 11 Best Cruelty-Free Nail Polish Brands in 2020
Now I’d like to hear from you. Have you tried any of the cruelty-free mascaras before? Please leave a comment below.
📌 Share this list of the best cruelty-free mascaras
